marking the end of an era with Blair

Martin Hall has handed over as director of the Cathedral Chamber Choir (which he founded) to Matthew O’Donovan and the occasion was marked by a special evensong including Blair in B minor (famously on the music list at Westminster Abbey the weekend after the 1997 General Election) and Parry’s I was glad. This music was chosen by Martin, who I gather is related to Hugh Blair.

The venue was Eton College Chapel. Architecturally and acoustically it’s a smaller version of King’s College Cambridge, with an impressively decorated organ. I missed a chance to come to the chapel some years ago when the New Cambridge Singers had a day trip there, so it was good to get another opportunity. And I hadn’t done the Blair in a long while, possibly because it’s in lots of parts throughout.

Posted in singing at services | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

admiring the candelabrum

In front of the choir stalls in Lincoln Cathedral there is a very fine candelabrum which attracted my attention (not least when two of the vergers were getting it lit before Sunday evensong). I think only Southwark has a better one. I was in Lincoln for a weekend of services with Priory Voices.

Most of the music was very familiar to me, and I commemorated the Elgar anniversary by singing The Spirit of the Lord is upon me. Actually, I don’t think I’ll be singing any other major work by Elgar this year. The piece new to me was O Salutaris Hostia by Rossini, who is becoming composer of the year for me after I learnt some of his songs and sang in his Stabat Mater. Like some of the other pieces we sang during the weekend, this was in a lower key than it is in some editions, but as I’d just got over a cold this was quite welcome.

This was a rare chance to celebrate a major festival (Pentecost) in a cathedral and so there were various extra bits of liturgy, and plainchant featured strongly. I did something which I’ve heard other choirs do but had never done myself: sang a plainchant antiphon before and after the Magnificat at the two evensongs.

I fitted in my usual visit to Imperial Teas (which has very recently moved across the road from where it used to be). My journey back home was, as often, wrecked by railway engineering work. Rather than having to face a roundabout route south via Nottingham I was very kindly offered a lift back to the rest of the family by another choir member who lived nearby.

I’d have liked to write at greater length about this, but I have a b[ack]log to get through. More posts soon.

Posted in singing at services | Tagged , , , | 1 Comment

Bath Festival 2007

There are various things I miss about the Festival these days: the fly-past of hot-air balloons followed by fireworks on the opening night, and the best-dressed window competition. And there’s no Bath Festival Chorus again this year. But we’ve been to four concerts so far between us and I’ll write about the two I attended.

Like the England cricket team, performers at the Festival this year seem to have been prone to injury and illness, and both concerts had a change of programme and performers. The cellist of Borodin Quartet on Tuesday night was a replacement for the sole original member of the quartet (and one of his pupils). The change of programme brought in Myaskovsky’s last quartet, written the year after he’d been denounced for formalism; I sensed he had written it looking over his shoulder. After Beethoven’s Op. 95 the concert really took wing with Tchaikovsky’s first quartet; until this point I felt the performers hadn’t quite settled into the music, perhaps because of the change of personnel. For a contrasting view of the Myaskovsky, see the Telegraph’s review here.

The following night I joined a party organised by a work collegue to hear Maxim Vengerov. I’ve written elsewhere about the early tickets and late start to this concert. Vengerov cut back his contribution to Mozart’s Adagio K261 and some encore-type pieces near the end. So we lost the Prokofiev and Shostakovich, and with them the opportunity to hear him in an extended work. Neverthess, I was glad to have heard as much of him as I did. With his direct approach, quite lacking in sentimentality but also not emptily virtuosic, he reminds me of great mid-20th century violinists such as Oistrakh.

Vengerov introduced some younger performers for the middle two pieces. Jack Liebeck and Katya Apekisheva played Elgar’s violin sonata which I could tell (I’d not seen a programme at this point) was a late work. It came over as a rather rambling piece, a lot of it slow. Adrian Brendel and Tim Horton played Beethoven’s cello sonata op. 5 no. 2. The slow introduction in particular anticipates the op. 13 piano sonata, though the rest doesn’t rise to the same level.

If I had the power I would invent a special kind of paper for use in concert programmes which would glow red-hot if it were used as a fan. I pay to see as well as hear the performers and it is very distracting to have a bit of paper waved in my line of view. I noticed the offenders (and most people who fanned themselves did so only between pieces) did this less when Vengerov was playing, and I don’t think it was cooler then, so they should have given Adrian Brendel & co. the same courtesy.

June 5: I won’t really have time to write properly about the third concert I attended, Purcell and Dowland performed by Emma Kirkby and Jakob Lindberg in the Assembly Rooms. I was glad of my front-row seat because of the intimate ambience the performers created (she sat down to sing all but the most dramatic of the songs) and the close-up views. (A feature of early-music concerts is how lovely many of the instruments look.)

Posted in going to concerts | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | 1 Comment

responses

I’ve sung quite a few different settings of these recently, and about 30 altogether, so here are some overall verdicts, as I haven’t a recent performance to write about. (For one thing, church is full of scaffolding!)

My favourite set: I’ve said this before – Lloyd second setting. A third Amen to die for! My favourite Tudor setting is the rather florid one by Tomkins. I have a fondness for the austere setting by Ebdon which turns up in Lent.

My least favourite (of the commonly sung settings): Clucas. They always sound out of tune even when they’re in tune! There are some others I’ve done which I think are considerably worse, but I won’t embarrass the people who’ve asked me to sing them by saying which ones they are.

Hardest: there are two ways of looking at this. I think the hardest from the point of view of learning notes are Howells’. For this reason, I have sung them barely three or four times and only now do I really feel secure about all the notes. But I find the hardest ones to sing as regards technique are Leighton’s. It’s all those floaty treble lines, and – a particular hazard in many settings of the responses – that there is no let-up or breathing space during the Lord’s Prayer.

Posted in repertoire | Tagged , , , , | 5 Comments

an alternative to singing

I was recently told that there’s a surplus of singers in Bristol at the moment and so all the choirs have waiting lists. I couldn’t help reflecting, firstly, on how things change over time. Not very long ago there were too many choirs in Bristol for the pool of singers available; this, I think, was what made the Brandon Hill Singers go under. Secondly, I wish good luck to the people on the waiting lists! I have been on several in my time: two choirs in Manchester, and round here the Paragon Singers and the Bristol Bach Choir (I’d enjoyed singing for Peter Leech so gave them a try, but they never contacted me when the season for auditions came round). In none of these cases did the wait lead to an audition and in at least one case I suspect the ‘waiting list’ to have been a total fiction rather than just carelessly maintained or scrapped after a certain length of time. It is a miserable alternative to singing.

[February 2015: A member of the Bristol Bach Choir told me that prospective members used sometimes to have to wait years for an audition, but now they get auditioned quickly.]

Posted in choirs | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

You know you’re a Purcell fan when …

you can’t log into your blog and see the little checkbox with the question ‘Remember me?’ without mentally carrying on ‘but ah! forget my fate’.

Posted in repertoire | Tagged | 9 Comments

two long Magnificats

I returned to St. Alban’s Cathedral rather sooner than expected, on the weekend of Low Sunday with the Peterborough Chamber Choir. I sang two evensongs, dashing off after the first one to a photoshoot followed by a College dinner in Cambridge. Both evensongs featured long Magnificats (the congregation were given a spoken dispensation to sit down). On the Saturday we sang the setting by Arvo Pärt, which I had long wanted to do. Now I’ll probably get to do it with lots of other groups.

On Sunday our Magnificat was the setting in B flat for double choir by Stanford. This always brings back memories of staring at the stained-glass windows in King’s College Chapel, trying to work out what the biblical stories in them were. I used to go to evensong there sometimes on Fridays, when they used unaccompanied settings to give their organ scholar a night off. This one seemed to crop up a great deal, in the days when no one else performed it very much. We did it rather faster than I’m used to, but otherwise it can be interminable!

Our Nuncs were Naylor in A and the Geoffrey Burgon setting. I hadn’t sung the latter before – it is one of few pieces of church music that I still associate with a TV series. Usually such associations are weak for me and easily broken.

Sunday was a big sing because we also did the Howells responses. At least I did not repeat the mistake I made in the 3rd Amen last time I sang 2nd soprano in these (it was one of the rare occasions when I really couldn’t find my note, rather than just being careless). The Pärt wasn’t the only new piece for me as we sang some responses by McPhee (very rarely done it seems) and a setting of Exultate Deo by Hendrik Andriessen, the first piece by him that I’d performed.

Posted in singing at services | Tagged , , , , , , , , | 2 Comments

Bruckner did not write heavy metal

But this didn’t stop the Grauniad from putting a spurious umlaut over the u in his surname today.

I recommend the Wikipedia article on this topic. I expect that I won’t be mentioning heavy metal again here in a hurry (or possibly Bruckner either). However I may post at some point some of the music-related corrections I’ve sent to the Grauniad over the last few years.

Posted in category-defying | Tagged | 1 Comment

a top C

I hadn’t been asked to do one of these in performance for a while (the last time I think was when I sang in the chorus in Mahler 8). But there was one at the end of a specially-written descant at the Easter Vigil Mass. The setting was Mozart’s Missa Brevis in G (with strings). As an anthem we sang Mozart’s Regina Cœli. This must have been written under the influence of the Messiah, to judge by the treatment of the Alleluias. One thing in common with the previous day’s Rossini: a female tenor soloist.

So concluded what must be the most memorable (musically) Holy Week/Easter I’ve had.

Posted in singing at services | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

Tribulation

The St. Matthew Passion wasn’t the only choral work I performed for the first time in Holy Week. On Good Friday I went over to Oxford to sing in a scratch performance of Rossini’s Stabat Mater at St. Giles’s Church (I did something similar three years ago).

I must admit to a soft spot for this particular work, for all that Rossini seems after the opening to have forgotten the actual meaning of the words he was setting. I hadn’t heard it for a while, but I must have listened to my recording of it enough in the past to have absorbed the tunes, because most of them came back easily enough. As well as the chorus movements, we also sang the two movements scored for the soloists as a quartet.

We used the Novello edition (I declined to borrow the ancient vocal score from our university library, fearing that my misreading of the soprano clef in my part would cause me to come in a third too high all the time). This has a curious ‘English version’ – the word ‘translation’ would be inappropriate – called ‘Tribulation’. It’s religious in a general kind of way, but makes no reference to the Virgin Mary – or her Son! (It is much further away from the Latin than the toned-down version in Hymns Ancient and Modern). Novello did this elsewhere, for example in the Coronation Mass where the Ordinary of the Mass is turned into some selections from the psalms.

Posted in singing in concerts | Tagged , , | 1 Comment

friendly and unfriendly choirs

Most choral singers must have had this experience: of trying to engage another in the choir in conversation, who has clearly decided that you aren’t in their league and can safely be ignored. I’ve already written about the time I rejoined a choir for a concert and only the conductor’s wife of the current singers spoke to me, and all those who weren’t regular members were shunted onto the back row regardless of height. Despite this experience I sang with them again a couple of years later. On my way to the first rehearsal I was approached by one of the other singers who on getting close said ‘Sorry, I thought you were a member of my choir!’ before walking away. To be fair, others did speak to me, though some spoiled the effect of familiarity by getting my name wrong.

It isn’t one particular choir; at a social event for another one I and one of the first sopranos arrived some time before anyone else. I can still recall the look of horror spreading across her face as she realised she had no choice but to talk to a second soprano!

It’s possible to find individual singers acting like this in a choir of any standard, and it’s only when it starts to infect an entire section that it really matters. For obvious reasons it tends to happen more in good choirs and it was rife in Cambridge; perhaps many people grow out of it when they cease to be students. I’ve come across very little of it in choirs which exist to visit cathedrals.

I suspect I was guilty of this myself when I went on tour with a well-known choir some years ago, towards singers in my section whom I suspected of having been included because their husbands were needed for tenor or bass sections (I’ve already written about this). Also my frustration with the lack of opportunities in Manchester and the feeling that mostly I was singing below my natural level must have been apparent at times.

Posted in choirs | Tagged | Comments Off on friendly and unfriendly choirs

the Chorus Angelorum

This was the name of the choir assembled to sing a big performance (really, there is no other kind) of Bach’s St. Matthew Passion in Bath Abbey tonight under the direction of Gavin Carr and accompanied by the English Chamber Orchestra.

I’d sung with about half the singers before in one place or another. The combined firepower of the choir was quite considerable, but I’d had a thorough audition for this concert so no one could question my right to be there. As the BFC performs increasingly infrequently, opportunities to sing with an orchestra of this calibre are rarer in the area now.

I’ve never really performed the St. Matthew Passion properly and it’s been on my wishlist. A long time ago I sang in a ‘come and sing’ performance in Oxford’s University Church with organ accompaniment; but the Evangelist fell ill and so his part had to be spoken! I’ve come close to doing it a number of times since then, most recently with the Exultate Singers a couple of years ago.

Despite this, I didn’t have much difficulty learning my part. I think I’ve heard the work so many times that it’s just sunk in at a subliminal level and I know what the key changes and most of the soprano lines are.

As in the last concert I sang in Bath Abbey, the interval had to be extended, but with more reason; someone in the audience fell ill (unlike the previous time when it was because two of the orchestra were still in the pub). If anyone who was there is reading this and hasn’t looked at the double-page spread just inside the back cover of the programme, I recommend doing so.

We sang in English, which fits the music well, though in some of the chorales in particular I looked enviously at the German because the meaning of the English had been watered down. At least it lacked the infelicities of the translation in the recording I have (‘You forsaken chickens’ being the most glaring example of this). We used the new Novello edition which has some decidedly tricky page-turns – I found myself writing v.s. all over the place – but I suppose that is inevitable in a piece with a lot of stops and starts for a choir (or often two choirs).

I won’t list all the soloists, otherwise people searching on their names will keep getting brought here. But I don’t think I’ve ever shared a concert platform with Emma Kirkby before, though I have heard her perform a few times, most recently in a Mahler 4. Actually in this piece my soloist fantasies focus more on the alto arias rather than the soprano ones (of course they also involve being given the vocal and interpretative abilities to do the music justice); here these were sung by Sarah Connolly.

My performance shouldn’t be detached from that of the rest of the choir; nevertheless I dedicated it to the memory of my old friend Philip Hall, whose funeral took place in Little St. Mary’s Church in Cambridge on the day of the concert.

Posted in singing in concerts | Tagged , , , , , | 3 Comments