three dead ends?

This September is a quiet month for singing, and in general this year so far has been quieter than I’d hoped despite the number of cathedral visits I’ve managed to fit in. I fell to reflecting on some sources of singing that have dried up or just never happened.

Yesterday I received a mailshot from the Exultate Singers about their forthcoming concerts. Seeing what they’d be doing I felt a distinct twinge of regret that I don’t sing with them any more.

When I left the Chantry Singers I asked to be added to the group of former members of the choir who augment it when larger numbers are needed, usually in the spring. As many in this group are quite a lot older than me, I rather expected to be a useful addition to it, but I haven’t been included in any concerts.

One thing I have taken direct action about is the dep list for the choir of the Lord Mayor’s Chapel in Bristol. Another group apparently dominated by those of advanced years, because when I tackled John Marsh about it he said that he preferred to call on retired people to stand in as deputies! (Perhaps this also explains why the Facebook group for this list is essentially dormant.) I’m sending one of my occasional reminders that I’m still interested in singing.

Posted in choirs | Tagged , , , , | 3 Comments

Bairstow caused the First World War

This was the rather startling allegation made by a member of the congregation to one of the Cathedral Chamber Choir after we’d performed Let all mortal flesh keep silence at the Sunday morning eucharist in York Minster. It seems that historians have overlooked the latent jingoism in his music when considering the origins of the Great War. ‘Think about that when you perform it!’

We didn’t have to wait long to reflect on Bairstow as warmonger because the afternoon’s anthem was Blessed City, heavenly Salem. Now I’m far from being a great fan of his music, but this was one objection to it which hadn’t occurred to me. And I can’t help feeling that if you dislike Bairstow’s music that strongly, then York Minster is probably the wrong place for you to go to church.

Our Mass setting was Rubbra’s Missa Sancti Domenici, which I remembered surprisingly well considering how long it was since I’d sung it. I’ve had a fresh chance to evaluate Rubbra’s choral music since I sang his evening canticles at Gloucester a few weeks ago, but I haven’t changed my view that writing choral music is one area where Cambridge’s academics definitely have the edge over Oxford’s (painful though it is to admit this). Although Cambridge does have to answer for Wood, whose Hail, gladdening Light we sang on Saturday and canticles in E flat (no. 2) on Sunday.

Lest this turn into a series of carps about repertoire, I’ll turn to some favourite pieces I sang at York. Friday was Gibbons night, with the Short Service and O clap your hands (I reacquainted myself with the second soprano part). Along with this was some wacky psalm pointing to keep us on our toes. On Saturday we sang the Leighton first service which I haven’t done properly for a few years; last time I sang it I didn’t have enough voice to do it justice.

A couple of Matins novelties I hadn’t sung before: Harris in A Benedicite (which tries to relieve the repetitive nature of the text by strewing little traps all along your path) and the Jubilate from Stanford in A.

The Sunday morning eucharist at York had the largest congregation I think I have ever sung to in an ordinary service. The full nave caught the Cathedral by surprise too, as the service booklets ran out. Perhaps Olympic success was having the same effect as Princess Diana’s death and causing a temporary increase in churchgoing.

Posted in singing at services | Tagged , , , , , , , , | 3 Comments

three days in Gloucester

The Erleigh Cantors did a long weekend this summer, including a Friday evensong. There were four services and a lot of music (we did introits) so I’ll just refer to some highlights.

The only totally new piece to me was the Langlais Messe Solennelle referred to in the last posting here. The organ was well suited to this piece, though the Benedictus must be one of the loudest pieces I’ve ever sung during communion! A few of us (myself included) put in the top C’s in the Hosannas.

New in part was Palestrina’s Tu es Petrus which I’ve only previously sung from a cut-down version, without the central section which is included in European Sacred Music.

We did again some music from previous visits, such as the Robert Fayrfax faux-bordon canticles (in fact only the Mag is by Fayrfax – the composer of the Nunc is unknown and the descant is by the editor!), Wood’s expansive canticles in F and Rubbra in A flat. This last was described by our conductor on a previous occasion as ‘a piece for organ and a piece for choir, to be performed simultaneously’! Also Lassus’ Justorum Animae, which we have been trying and failing to slip into the order of service as an introit for a couple of years!

Some things about Gloucester haven’t changed since I visited with Priory Voices in 2003. The five-and-a-half octave piano in the choir rehearsal room hasn’t been replaced yet, and it can still take a long time to get served with food and drink (I’m not especially thinking of the Cathedral refectory here).

Posted in singing at services | Tagged , , , , , , , | 1 Comment

requirements for the Langlais Messe Solennelle

I sang this in Gloucester Cathedral in July (writeup to follow) and was asked by the conductor of another choir to say whether I thought it would be viable for one of his cathedral weekends. Here’s the list of minimum requirements I gave, with some specifics omitted. The choir is composed of good sight-singers and meets without prior rehearsal, but music and recordings are supplied to members in advance.

a) an organ capable of doing the work justice (Gloucester’s certainly is)
b) an organist of similar capabilities!
c) 3-4 sopranos who can reliably hit the top C’s in the Hosannas. Strictly speaking these are optional and don’t even appear in the choir scores, but congregations who’ve heard the work will expect them. It’s like interpolated high notes in operatic arias. [I’m told that when Langlais heard about this interpolated note he said that he would have written it himself, but didn’t think choirs would be able to attempt it.] I know of no other work one might sing in a church service which has a top C for the choir trebles/sopranos (as opposed to a soloist).
d) a quorum of singers who have done the work before who can lead their sections. I would say one on each part on each side. This work is hard to learn in advance from a score and a CD for reason e) below.
e) adequately annotated scores. You need a second mortgage to afford a full score, and the ‘choir’ version has no leads or anything else from the organ part in it. I had a hired copy which had some leads pencilled in, which helped a lot with learning.

Posted in repertoire | Tagged , | 1 Comment

a fleeting trip to Worcester

I paid a brief visit to Worcester Cathedral on Saturday July 19th to sing Evensong. This was (nominally) a Priory Voices event, with a large admixture of Congleton Choral Society singers. Unfortunately I couldn’t do the whole weekend, so missed the Widor Mass on the Sunday. Saturday’s music was Noble in B minor and They that go down by Sumsion and Neary responses. The Quire organ wasn’t quite ready for us so we sang in the Nave with a temporary instrument. It was a shame not to get much chance to socialise but I’ll be back with the choir in Wells in the autumn.

Next up: a write up of the Erleigh Cantors in Gloucester.

Posted in singing at services | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

a fiesta of vibrant choral music

That was my tagline for the Facebook entry for the Chandos Singers’ recent concert of Latin American baroque music. This covered some of the same ground as the Latin American concert I sang with the Exultate Singers a while back. In fact, three of the same pieces reappeared, so maybe a standard concert repertory for this area is emerging already, at least for vernacular pieces. Anyway there was some variety as the interpretations this time round weren’t necessarily similar.

The Latin sacred pieces, by Franco and de Padilla (including his Mass Ego flos campi), were all new to me. For the second concert in a row we sang a setting of the Marian litany, a text whose repetitiveness is clearly a challenge to composers. Here it was varied rhythms which were used to make it interesting.

I still don’t have much of a picture of what conditions were like for the composers of these pieces. Were they working on their own in a remote church in a clearing hacked out of the jungle, with no contact with other composers and not seeing any recently published music – so forced to go their own way? Or were they the first down at the docks when a ship came in from Spain bearing editions of the latest choral works from Europe?

Posted in singing in concerts | Tagged , , | 1 Comment

DD

I am performing Wood’s ‘Collegium Regale’ evening canticles shortly with the Erleigh Cantors, for the first time in a while. These pieces rather unusually have rehearsal letters in (I have a legally photocopied reprint of a 1920 ‘Year Book Press’ edition). Church music tends not to use them, because the pieces aren’t very long and everyone usually has identical copies with all bars written out, so you can refer to page or bar numbers in rehearsal. (An exception is the type of irritating French edition which omits the organ part and organ-only bars. I’m performing from one of those soon as well, but will leave it for another post).

Rehearsal letters in the Magnificat of Wood ‘Coll. Reg.’ run from A-K, with a curious exception: a ‘DD’ between D and E at the top of page 6 in my edition. DD’s when used as rehearsal letters generally occur in very long movements after you’ve run through the alphabet from A-Z and have to start again with AA. So what is this one doing here? I know Wood was Irish, but was the editor Welsh? Is it something to do with bra sizes? Or more boringly did they simply find that the gap between D and E was too large and they needed an intermediate rehearsal letter?

Posted in published music | Tagged | Leave a comment

another return to St Alban’s

When I last sang with Lyra Davidica, Princess Diana was alive and Sri Lanka were scoring 952/6 against India (I recall someone bursting into breakfast on that choir tour brandishing a newspaper: ‘Just LOOK at THIS!!’). In the meantime I faded from the memories of most people associated with the choir, but I remained on the email list and was able to join a choir weekend at St Alban’s at the end of May. (St. Alban’s Abbey/Cathedral is beginning to feel like a home from home; this is the third time I have sung there in 18 months, with 3 different choirs. In fact I was also invited to sing there on the previous Monday, with yet another choir, but was doing the B minor mass instead.)

The music for the evensong and Eucharist that we sang was well-known to me, with the exception of Brian Moles’ setting of ‘At the round earth’s imagined corners’ which I believe the choir premiered recently. The Cathedral is in a certain amount of disarray at the moment as the organ is being rebuilt and there is scaffolding in the nave which reduces the acoustic; but I can see why they might want to do these two pieces of work at the same time.

Posted in singing at services | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

grade 1 piano

My daughter did Grade 1 piano about a week ago. I cast my mind back to dim memories when I was doing the same exam and tried to compare the experiences. For one thing, the Associated Board has livened up the covers of its exam books a bit from the dreary monochrome grey and brown ones I remember. Within, the pieces are not as easy as I’d expected and you now do one in a jazzier style (at least my daughter did). I think this is a good thing as I didn’t really get to grips with jazz rhythms at that stage and still find them a challenge at times (for example in the Birthday Madrigals by Rutter a couple of years ago). They are definitely a part of being musically literate.

Posted in children, piano/organ | 1 Comment

a plea to the Barbican

To make it up to my daughter for having forgotten the LSO concert at the Bath Festival, my husband took her to the Barbican in London to hear the same performers and composers, but different symphonies (Schubert’s Unfinished and Bruckner’s 6th). He carefully calculated the length of the pieces from our recordings, allowed a little extra for luck and booked tickets for a particular train back to Bath afterwards accordingly.

However all these calculations were thrown when an extra piece appeared on the programme unheralded. It turned out to be Azalea Fragments by Joe Duddell, conducted by Pavel Kotla. The composer took a bow, but few in the audience knew who he was, as in order to find out you would have had to have bought the full programme, rather than just picking up the programme notes as my family and most of the rest of the audience had done.

Now it’s good to have a new piece programmed alongside war-horses, but why was it so hard to find out what it was called, what it was about, who wrote it, who conducted it and some biography about these people? Even the full programme only gave the names of the performers and the piece, and a relative of my husband’s who deps in the LSO happened to be playing but couldn’t supply any more details. The Barbican is festooned with information screens which could have given some clue, or someone could have stood up and said a few words before the performance.

My gripe isn’t just about this but also that the extra unpublicised piece in the concert created problems for the return train journey (a taxi did get them there in time). Are concert audiences in London really so frightened of new music that they won’t come if it’s advertised in advance? The Barbican did something similar when I last went to a concert there, a few years ago; there was a lengthy speech which caused the concert to end some ten minutes later than expected.

So I would repeat what I said in a letter to the management after that concert; remember that a part of your audience comes from outside London and may be booked on a particular train out of London. If the concert ends significantly later than scheduled, they may miss that train, which could mean the difference between being home at midnight and being home at 2 a.m., and could be expensive if their ticket was valid for the earlier train only, as cheaper tickets generally now are. Even if this doesn’t happen, their enjoyment of the concert will be spoiled by worries about the return journey. If they are regular concert-goers in London, they may desert the Barbican in favour of venues where concerts end at a predictable time.

The Guardian reviewed the concert here, the Times here, both very favourably, and the Sunday Times complains about lack of information about the Duddell here.

Posted in going to concerts | Tagged , , , , , | Leave a comment

two other 2008 Bath Festival concerts

I wasn’t able to attend more than two concerts because of my own singing commitments during the Festival but others in the family got out more. My husband went to the concert of Indian classical music given by Partho Sarothy and Kausik Sen at the Invention Studios. There used to be more Indian music in Bath – perhaps to entertain people who’d retired there after serving in the Raj – but now you usually have to go to Bristol to hear it. The concert was good but the venue rather gloomy with its dark walls.

He also took our elder son to hear Natalie Clein and Kathy Stott. This was our son’s first concert and we noticed throughout the festival that there were a few more young people at concerts than in some previous years. They thought the Rachmaninov op. 19 cello sonata came off best; the programme also contained one of Bach’s cello suites. Shostakovich’s op. 40 sonata had the feel of a piece written by someone who was still getting a feel for the instrument and not trying anything too daring. The concert ended with a tango by Piazzolla (who also supplied the encore). Suddenly there seems to be a lot of his music around and while it is enjoyable to listen to I’m not sure how much real merit it has and whether he will survive being currently flavour of the month.

Posted in going to concerts | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | 3 Comments

two piano recitals

I have a great backlog of recent/current events to write about. I’ll continue with a further writeup of the 2008 Bath Festival.

We had a ticket for Alfredo Perl, but sadly he was nursing an injury and pulled out, taking the Schoenberg and Diabelli Variations on his programme with him. His replacement was Jean-Efflam Bavouzet playing an early Beethoven sonata, Ravel and Debussy. My husband went and enjoyed the performances but wondered whether the pianist was playing the programme he’d have chosen if he’d been given an absolutely free hand. In particular, was he really wanting to play Gaspard de la Nuit?

The reason he couldn’t was that this piece ended Yevgeny Sudbin’s recital a few days later. I went to this and had no complaints about the technical standard, though what I missed was a sense of the artist’s personality coming through. I wish he’d played more Chopin (we had two mazurkas) as for me that came off best. We also heard two Haydn sonatas and a selection of early Scriabin mazurkas which didn’t convert me to that composer. The encores were generous in length.

We appreciated the ice-cream which is now on sale, along with coffee and muffins, in the interval of concerts at the Assembly Rooms. (But you need be quick to join the queue to have time to eat it!)

Posted in going to concerts, piano/organ | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , | 2 Comments